How to Evaluate an SEO Agency

Most SEO agencies are not bad people. They're just operating in a market where confident-sounding nonsense is hard to distinguish from genuine expertise. This guide won't make you an expert — but it'll make you a harder person to fool.

Most agencies are not bad people.

Most SEO agencies aren't bad people — they're operating in a market where confident-sounding nonsense is hard to distinguish from genuine expertise. This guide won't make you an SEO expert. But it'll make you a harder person to fool, and the questions here should filter out most of the bad fits before you sign anything.

Start with the basics: can they explain what they do?

Before evaluating any agency's SEO skills, evaluate whether they can communicate clearly. Good agencies explain their process in plain language. If an agency is vague about what they do, hides behind jargon, or deflects when you ask specifics, that's not a sign of proprietary expertise — it's a deflection strategy. Ask them: what would you specifically do for my site in the first 90 days? Listen for concrete, sensible answers.

Questions worth asking before you sign anything

These aren't trick questions. They're reasonable things a legitimate agency should answer confidently:

→Can you show me results you've achieved for businesses similar to mine — same industry, similar market size?
→What does your reporting include — rankings, traffic, or actual leads and enquiries?
→What does your process look like in the first 30, 60, 90 days?
→How do you build links? Specifically — what kinds of sites and how do you get them?
→What happens to my rankings if I stop working with you?
→Do I own all the content and assets you create?
→What's a realistic timeline for results in my market?

Red flags that should end the conversation

Some things are disqualifying regardless of how confident the pitch sounds:

→Guaranteed page 1 rankings — no one can guarantee this, and the ones who promise it know they can't deliver it
→Very cheap pricing — real SEO work takes skilled time; $200/month retainers are usually dashboard access, not actual work
→'Proprietary strategies' or 'we can't reveal our process' — translation: we don't want you to know what we're doing
→Lock-in contracts of 12+ months before you've seen a single result
→They rank you for your own business name and call that SEO

The most common scam

An agency shows you a ranking report with 50 keywords you now appear for. Most of them are low-volume, branded, or terms no one searches. The one you actually care about — 'electrician Parramatta' — is on page 6. The report looks impressive until you read it carefully.

What good reporting actually looks like

Vanity metrics are easy to inflate. A useful SEO report shows: organic traffic to specific target pages (not just site-wide totals), keyword rankings for terms with actual search volume in your market, conversions from organic traffic (enquiries, calls, form fills), technical health over time, and the specific actions taken that month. A report that connects activity to outcomes is a report. A monthly dashboard of swelling keyword counts with no revenue context is a distraction.

Realistic timelines

Legitimate SEO takes 3–6 months to show meaningful movement and 12 months to properly evaluate. If an agency quotes faster results, ask specifically what metric they're measuring and on what timeline. For local, low-competition terms: 4–8 weeks is possible. For competitive national terms: 12–18 months is realistic. Anyone promising faster results for competitive keywords is overselling.

Before the first call

Copy these three questions and email them before agreeing to any consultation. The replies will tell you most of what you need to know before a single meeting takes place.

Question 1

Can you show me results for a business in my industry — with before/after traffic or ranking data?

Question 2

What specifically would you do in my first 90 days, and what would I be able to see at the end of it?

Question 3

What's your link-building process, specifically?

Note

If any answer is vague, evasive, or pivots to booking a call instead of answering the question directly — that pivot is your answer.

Key takeaways

If they can't explain what they do in plain language, that's a deflection strategy — not expertise
Ask for results from businesses similar to yours, not logo walls or generic case studies
Guaranteed rankings, very cheap pricing, and 12-month lock-ins before results are all disqualifying
A useful report connects organic traffic to real outcomes — not keyword counts
SEO takes 3–6 months to move meaningfully and 12 months to properly evaluate

Keep reading

Related guides

Hiring & Vetting

If Someone Cold Emails You About SEO, Ask These Questions

How to separate a legitimate offer from a bulk-spam scam in under five minutes.

Read guide

SEO Fundamentals

What SEO Actually Is

Crawling, indexing, ranking — the mechanics behind how Google decides who wins.

Read guide

SEO Fundamentals

What SEO Is Not

Busting the myths that cost small businesses money and time.

Read guide

We answer all of these questions upfront.

Our process, our link-building approach, realistic timelines for your market, and what you'll see at 30, 60, and 90 days — all on our services page, before you ever contact us.

Get a Quote